PeaceApril 15, 20265 min read

Finding Peace in Uncertainty

When the path ahead feels unclear, there is grace in learning to be still.

By Carla Bosteder, M.Ed.

Finding Peace in Uncertainty

If you've been searching for peace of mind or some sense of inner peace, you're not alone in that search. There is a particular kind of exhaustion that comes from trying to see around corners - from attempting to map out a future that refuses to be mapped. If you know that feeling, I want you to hear something right now. That exhaustion is not a sign that your faith is weak. It's a sign that you're human, and you're carrying something heavy.

I've been in that place where I wasn't even tired from doing things. I was tired from thinking about things. Running scenarios at 2 a.m., rehearsing conversations that hadn't happened yet, trying to control outcomes by worrying about them hard enough - as if worry were a form of preparation. It isn't. But it feels like it is, and that's part of what makes it so hard to stop.

And here's what I wish someone had told me sooner: there's nothing wrong with you for feeling that way. When we face situations we can't predict or control, our nervous system reads that as a threat. It floods us with stress hormones, keeps us scanning for danger, won't let us settle. That tight chest, the thoughts that won't stop spinning - that's not a character flaw. That's your body trying to protect you from something it can't see. And knowing that matters, because once you understand what's happening in your body, you can stop piling shame on top of something that's already heavy enough.

What "Be Still" Actually Means

Psalm 46:10 says, "Be still, and know that I am God."

I used to read that verse and feel like I was failing at it. Like "be still" meant "calm down," and I couldn't. But the Hebrew word there - raphah - it means something closer to "let go." Release your grip. Stop white-knuckling the outcome.

That changed everything for me. Because releasing your grip is not the same thing as feeling calm. You can let go of an outcome with shaking hands. You can surrender something to God while tears are running down your face. That's not weak faith. Honestly, I think that might be the bravest kind there is.

So if you've tried to "just trust God" and felt like a failure when the anxiety didn't lift - can I just sit with you in that for a second? Because that's not a faith problem. That's a human being doing something incredibly hard, and doing it anyway.

Why the Not-Knowing Is So Exhausting

Here's something that helped me understand my own anxiety in uncertain seasons. Our brains are wired to complete patterns, to finish the story, to know how things turn out. When we can't - when we're stuck in a chapter with no resolution - it creates a kind of tension that is genuinely distressing. It's not the situation itself that's so hard. It's the not-knowing.

And that's why two women can be walking through the same kind of waiting season and one feels mostly okay while the other can barely function. It has nothing to do with who loves God more. It has everything to do with how each person's nervous system processes the unknown.

So if yours processes it with dread, with a knot in your stomach that just won't untangle - that says nothing about the quality of your relationship with God. What it might mean is that you need different tools than someone who navigates uncertainty more easily. Not better faith. Just different tools.

The Practice of Small Faithfulness

Something I've learned in seasons of transition is to stop trying to figure out the big picture and just anchor myself in small things. Not grand gestures. Quiet, daily, almost boring things.

  • Morning pages, written without any agenda
  • A walk at the same hour, noticing the same trees
  • Reading one page of something true
  • Lighting a candle before dinner

I know those might sound too simple to matter. But there's a real reason they work, and it has everything to do with how God made us.

When your external world is unpredictable, small consistent rhythms give your brain something it can rely on. Over time, your body starts to associate certain cues - the smell of coffee, the feel of a pen, the same path through the neighborhood - with safety. And that starts to settle your nervous system before you even consciously think about it. God designed our bodies to respond to rhythm and rest. He built the entire created world on cycles - sunrise, sunset, seasons, tides. So when we build small rhythms into uncertain days, we're actually aligning ourselves with how He made things to work.

And then there's the noticing. Anxiety is almost always about the future. It pulls you out of right now and into a hundred imagined scenarios. But when you stop and feel the warmth of a mug or watch the way light falls through a window, you're gently pulling yourself back to what's real. Jesus talked about this in Matthew 6:34 - "So do not worry about tomorrow; for tomorrow will worry about itself. Each day has enough trouble of its own." He wasn't dismissing legitimate concern. He was telling us something about how we were built to live. One day at a time.

Writing helps too, and not because journaling is trendy. When everything stays in your head, it just spins. But something happens when you put it on paper - even messy, even half-sentences, even just a few words scrawled in the margin of whatever's closest. You take a thought that felt like a fact and you put it outside yourself where you can actually look at it. And a thought you can look at is a thought you can bring to God.

David did this constantly. He didn't filter his anguish before bringing it to God. He just wrote it, raw and unpolished. "How long, O Lord? Will You forget me forever?" (Psalm 13:1). That's not pretty faith. That's a man pouring out what was eating him alive so he could hand it over.

When Even the Small Things Feel Like Too Much

I want to be real about something, though. There are seasons when even these small practices feel like more than you can manage. When getting out of bed is the whole victory. When the idea of lighting a candle before dinner sounds nice, but you can barely pull dinner together in the first place.

If that's where you are right now, please hear me. You're not behind. You're not doing this wrong.

The woman who journals for twenty minutes and the woman who can only manage a few breaths before the tears come - they're both showing up. God doesn't measure faithfulness by output. He meets you in the showing up, whatever that looks like today. Even if it looks like lying on the couch with your Bible open to a page you're too tired to read.

Psalm 34:18 - "The Lord is near to the brokenhearted and saves those who are crushed in spirit."

Near. Not waiting for you to pull yourself together first. Just near.

Something Simple to Try This Week

If you're in a season of uncertainty right now, I want to offer you one small practice. Not a formula, not a fix. Just something to try.

Each morning this week, before you check your phone, before the scenarios start running, write down three things you know for certain. They can be as small as you need them to be.

The coffee is hot.
The dog is sleeping at my feet.
The scripture I read this morning is true.

I know it sounds almost too simple. But what you're really doing is training your brain to notice what's stable instead of fixating on what's not. You're building a small daily record of certainty in a season that doesn't offer much of it. And over time, instead of waking up and immediately scanning for what might go wrong, your mind starts scanning for what's solid. It's a small shift. But it's a real one.

Paul wrote about this in Philippians 4:8 - "Whatever is true, whatever is honorable, whatever is right, whatever is pure, whatever is lovely, whatever is commendable, if there is any excellence and if anything worthy of praise, think about these things." He wasn't saying ignore reality. He was saying when reality feels unbearable, aim your attention toward what's still true. What some call mindfulness for anxiety, Scripture calls fixing your mind on what is true.

One Last Thing

I'm not going to tell you this uncertain season will resolve quickly, or that someday it'll all make sense. It might. It might not. Some chapters of our lives never fully explain themselves this side of heaven, and honestly, I think pretending otherwise does more harm than good.

But I will tell you what I know to be true.

You are not alone in this. Not in the abstract, greeting-card way. In the Psalm 23 way - "Even though I walk through the valley of the shadow of death, I fear no evil, for You are with me."

Through. Not around it. Not above it. Through.

God does not wait for you to figure it out before He shows up. He is already there - in the not-knowing, in the 2 a.m. thoughts, in that heavy exhale when someone asks how you're doing and you say "fine" because the real answer would take an hour.

He's with you there.

And that - not a clear path, not a guaranteed outcome, not a five-year plan - that's where real peace lives. Not in certainty, but in the One who is certain.

May you find Him there today.

More Resources

If you're looking for inspiring Christian verses on finding peace in uncertain times, these are worth sitting with:

  • Psalm 46:10 - on being still and knowing God is in control
  • Philippians 4:6-7 - on bringing anxiety to God and receiving peace that surpasses understanding
  • Isaiah 26:3 - on perfect peace for the mind fixed on God
  • John 14:27 - on the peace Jesus gives being different from what the world offers
  • Psalm 23:1-4 - on God as shepherd through uncertain valleys
  • Proverbs 3:5-6 - on trusting God rather than leaning on your own understanding

I created Simplify to Glorify for women of faith who are walking through hard seasons and need more than just encouragement — they need something to hold onto. I hold an M.Ed. in Curriculum Development, and I design every resource with both purpose and compassion. Honest. Grace-filled. Right where you are.— Carla Bosteder, M.Ed.